In a move that sent shockwaves across the NFL, the Miami Dolphins brought back former All-Pro safety Minkah Fitzpatrick in a high-stakes trade with the Pittsburgh Steelers this offseason. The Dolphins took on Fitzpatrick’s $17 million-per-year contract hoping for a defensive resurgence, but early signs point to trouble. Analysts already predict Fitzpatrick could be the team’s biggest “bust” of the 2025 season, raising questions about what the Pittsburgh Steelers truly gained—and what they may need to do next.
The Trade: A Bold Gamble by Miami
Miami’s decision to trade Jalen Ramsey and Jonnu Smith for Fitzpatrick shocked many fans and insiders alike. While Fitzpatrick was a fan favorite in his early years with the Dolphins, his production has noticeably declined over the past two seasons. Last year with the Steelers, he finished with just one interception and allowed opposing QBs to complete over 70% of passes thrown his way.
Despite the high price tag and declining stats, Miami made a nostalgic bet. But now, early training camp reports out of Miami suggest Fitzpatrick is struggling to find his rhythm in the new defensive scheme. Some insiders are already labeling him a $17 million liability rather than the defensive centerpiece the Dolphins envisioned.
What This Means for the Steelers
From Pittsburgh’s perspective, this trade might be addition by subtraction. Fitzpatrick’s declining play, paired with his hefty contract, made him expendable. In return, they received Jalen Ramsey, a versatile and still high-performing cornerback, who many believe is a better scheme fit under Mike Tomlin’s aggressive defense.
So what do the Steelers need to do to ensure this move pays off?
1. Rebuild the Safety Unit
With Fitzpatrick gone, the Steelers have a noticeable hole at free safety. They’ll likely rotate a mix of veterans and younger players—possibly bringing in a free agent or elevating a draft pick. Keeping the secondary strong without Fitzpatrick will be a key test early in the season.
2. Maximize Jalen Ramsey’s Versatility
Ramsey isn’t just a cornerback—he can line up at safety, nickel, or even blitz off the edge. The Steelers must use this flexibility to disguise coverages and compensate for the loss of Fitzpatrick’s deep-field awareness.
3. Capitalize on the Cap Space
Moving Fitzpatrick’s contract frees up much-needed salary cap room. The Steelers can use that money to extend T.J. Watt, shore up depth at linebacker, or invest in offensive line help—key areas for a playoff push with veteran QB Aaron Rodgers at the helm.
4. Let Fitzpatrick’s Struggles Validate the Move
As Fitzpatrick continues to struggle in Miami, it only strengthens the Steelers’ case for moving on at the right time. If he fails to live up to the $17 million price tag, Pittsburgh can confidently say they dodged a financial and performance-related bullet.
Final Thoughts
The Fitzpatrick trade is quickly turning into one of the offseason’s most polarizing stories. While the Dolphins may be staring down one of the year’s biggest busts, the Steelers appear to be better positioned—both financially and on the field. If Pittsburgh continues to build smartly around their defense and Ramsey delivers, this move could mark a Turning point toward serious Super Bowl contention.
Be the first to comment